Pickering neighbourhood guide

West Shore

West Shore is the quieter side of Frenchman's Bay, a lakefront community of big lots, tall trees and long views where Pickering's cottage era never quite ended. Settlers farmed the tableland above the lake in the 1800s, and the Nesbitt-Newman House of the 1850s at 560 Park Crescent, on the City's Municipal Heritage Register, is the one building left from that time. Toronto families put up summer cottages along the bay and the bluffs in the early 1900s, ice was cut on the bay for the Lake Simcoe Ice company from 1914 into the 1930s, and after Highway 401 arrived the cottages were winterized and the fields between them were subdivided in the 1960s. Today the streets south of Bayly hold ranch bungalows, two-storey houses and a steady crop of custom rebuilds, with Rotary Frenchman's Bay West Park, the marina and yacht club, and Petticoat Creek Conservation Park as the daily backdrop. The West Shore Community Centre on Bayly Street, Father Fenelon Catholic School and Fairport Beach Public School give it a village feel, and the Whites Road interchange puts the 401 at the top of the hill.

West Shore homes by the numbers

Live from the MLS® feed · updated October 8, 2026

27 For sale now
13 New in 30 days
$849,900 Median asking price Middle half $594K to $1.3M
$554 Asking price per sq ft
34 days Median days listed
18% Listings with a price cut Median cut 4.5%

What is for sale: 15 detached homes · 11 townhouses · 1 semi-detached homes

Newest West Shore homes for sale

See all 27 listings

New West Shore homes for sale land here first. Save this search and we email you the moment one is listed.

Where West Shore sits

West Shore is the southwest corner of Pickering, held between Petticoat Creek on the west, Frenchman's Bay on the east, Highway 401 on the north and Lake Ontario on the south. Bayly Street crosses the top of the community near the Whites Road interchange, and West Shore Boulevard drops from Bayly to the lake with Oklahoma Drive, Park Crescent, Eyer Drive and Sunrise Avenue branching off it. The bayfront streets were historically called Fairport, a name that survives in the local public school.

The homes you will find

Two bands of housing make up West Shore. North of the middle, toward Bayly Street, the 1970s and 1980s streets carry neo-colonial and neo-tudor two-storey houses in single-colour brick with attached garages on standard lots, the kind of family subdivision found across Pickering. South of that, on the streets nearest the bay and the bluffs, the lots widen and the stock changes: 1960s ranch bungalows and side-splits on deep properties, two-storey houses from the 1970s, and a growing number of custom homes built on the footprint of a cottage or bungalow, many designed around a view of Frenchman's Bay or the open lake. Townhouse rows and a few low-rise apartment buildings sit near Bayly Street and along West Shore Boulevard, giving the community an entry point. Because so many houses began as cottages or have been rebuilt in stages, permits, surveys and the location of the top of bank matter more here than in a newer subdivision.

Getting around

The Whites Road interchange on Highway 401 sits at the community's northern edge, so drivers are on the highway within minutes and at Highway 407 by continuing north on Whites Road. Pickering GO is a short drive or bus ride east along Bayly Street, where the 917 Pulse runs between the Pickering Parkway Terminal, Ajax GO and Whitby GO; Durham Region Transit's peak-hour 920 threads West Shore Boulevard and Oklahoma Drive on its way to Scarborough Centre station, which suits commuters bound for the subway rather than the train. On summer weekends and holidays the City's free Waterfront Route 100 bus links the beaches on both sides of the bay. The Waterfront Trail runs through Petticoat Creek Conservation Park and along the bayfront, and the residential streets are quiet enough for cycling, though the climb back up from the lake is real. Most errands still involve a car.

Schools

Public elementary students go to Fairport Beach Public School, Frenchman's Bay Public School or Rosebank Road Public School depending on the street, with Frenchman's Bay reportedly hosting a French immersion program, and then to Dunbarton High School at 655 Sheppard Avenue, opened in 1961 and run on two campuses by the Durham District School Board. Father Fenelon Catholic School at 795 Eyer Drive is the neighbourhood Catholic elementary and sends students to St. Mary, the Catholic secondary school on Whites Road. Families wanting French-language education have Viamonde's public Ronald-Marion schools in Pickering and MonAvenir's Catholic Notre-Dame-de-la-Jeunesse in Ajax and Saint-Charles-Garnier in Whitby. Each board draws its own boundaries and revises them, so confirm the school for a specific address before making it part of the decision.

Parks, shopping and daily life

Petticoat Creek Conservation Park at 1100 Whites Road South is the big draw: a TRCA park on the bluffs with lake views, six picnic sites, dozens of tree species and the Waterfront Trail running through, open daily from early May to mid-September in 2026 and on weekends into the fall. Its outdoor pool, 49 years old, was closed for good after a 2020 assessment, and the authority is exploring a splash pad in its place. Rotary Frenchman's Bay West Park has the beach and the west side of the harbour entrance, Bruce Handscomb Memorial Park and Cliffview Park sit on the bay and the bluff, and the yacht club and marina fill the west shore of the bay itself. The West Shore Community Centre at 1011 to 1015 Bayly Street hosts programs and rentals. Groceries and daily errands are on Whites Road at the plaza near Bayly, the mall on Kingston Road is ten minutes away, and Lakeridge Health Ajax Pickering is the hospital.

Who it suits

West Shore suits buyers who want land and water more than convenience: families after a deep lot and a quiet street, custom-home buyers who want to build toward a lake view, sailors with a slip on the bay, and anyone who walks the Waterfront Trail daily. It is not the place for someone who wants to walk to the GO train, rely on frequent buses or find a condo tower, and bluff-edge and bayfront lots carry erosion and flood considerations that need a TRCA conversation before you fall for the view.

Questions people ask about West Shore

Are West Shore lots exposed to flooding or erosion?

Some are. Bayfront properties sit in areas the Toronto and Region Conservation Authority regulates for flooding and shoreline hazards, and lots along the bluffs and the Petticoat Creek valley have a regulated top of bank. Ask for the TRCA mapping, look at the slope and drainage on site, and get a geotechnical opinion before planning a rebuild or pool.

Is the Petticoat Creek pool coming back?

No. TRCA closed the 49-year-old aquatic facility permanently after a 2020 assessment found major infrastructure and equipment problems, and it is pursuing grants and partners for a possible splash pad or other leisure facility instead. The park itself stays open seasonally with picnic areas, the bluffs and the Waterfront Trail.

How do West Shore residents commute?

Mostly by car up Whites Road to the 401, which is minutes from every street. Train commuters drive or bus along Bayly Street to Pickering GO; the peak-hour 920 bus through West Shore Boulevard and Oklahoma Drive reaches Scarborough Centre for subway riders; the 917 Pulse on Bayly connects the GO stations in Pickering, Ajax and Whitby.

Which schools will my children attend in West Shore?

Fairport Beach, Frenchman's Bay or Rosebank Road public schools, then Dunbarton High School on Sheppard Avenue; Father Fenelon Catholic School on Eyer Drive, then St. Mary Catholic Secondary on Whites Road. The public and Catholic boards set the lines street by street and change them, so treat any listing's school claim as something to verify.

Can I replace an old cottage with a new house?

Owners do it regularly on the streets near the bay and the bluffs. Zoning governs height, coverage and setbacks, the City's tree by-law protects the mature canopy, and lots near the water or the ravine need TRCA permission. Order a survey early, because cottage-era boundaries and encroachments are common, and confirm whether any heritage listing applies.

Sources: neighbourhoodguide.com · hoodq.com · en.wikipedia.org · trca.ca · trca.ca · pickering.ca